How Big Will The Impact Of The Skill Node Nerf Be?

The devs’ ongoing struggle to contain botters in the game continued yesterday with the announcement that skill nodes will be nerfed and no longer dropping any refining points. It’s been a vital point in the last months to erase botted Astral Diamonds and Refining Points from the economy through several Leadership changes and the removal of skill nodes. Unfortunately botters found new places where they could farm every time and in the end Cryptic does what they’ve always done: Pull the plug.

Nerfing everything to the ground the bots touch is a testament to helplessness. The devs obviously can’t attach any resources to hunting bots, so they must rely on ingame changes to solve the situation. But this always comes at the expense of the legit players, an issue discussed on this site before. Granted, skill nodes were already capped in a way that you would only get Junk loot if you farmed too many in a certain time interval, but players instantly lose an asset anyway. Raising the drop chance of Insignias and open world drops of Enchantments and Runestones look good on paper though. Players that were actually farming nodes might not lose any efficiency if they are going for mobs in their Stronghold for example. Time will tell.

I’m not sure why they didn’t simply made RPs from skill nodes bound though. Sure, bound RPs would still be an issue in terms of player bots, but I think in the first place you want to limit the professionals, which a change of the bind status would have achieved perfectly. In the end they simply decided to take the fastest and cheapest route once again instead of introducing true anti-botting measures. They ignored viable alternatives to nerfs in the past, like a gateway captcha. Apparently even one of their own games offers a solution for skill nodes, because Star Trek Online has implemented some mini-game to protect against botters. This should work on Neverwinter as well, right? Overall the change at least hits botters more than the players and it’s possible additional RPs will be infused in other areas when the impact of the change to the economy will be known.

The market reacted heavily to the expected lower supply yesterday. Stacks of Rank 5 Enchantments and Runestones doubled almost instantly and tripled over the course of the evening. The overall effect on the prices however is highly uncertain and depends on a few variables that are hard to foresee. So far bots have been able to live through all nerfs the devs have thrown their way, and they will adopt once again. Skill nodes have received significant changes already to no avail, so removing them as source might not have as big of an impact. Open world farming is not only still possible, but now even comes with enhanced drop rates of RPs. It’s safe to assume that the output of each bot will likely be lower, but maybe not as low as the current heavy market reaction makes us believe.

With RPs from skill nodes gone, the ones from Leadership become more important, which could lead to bots and players switching to the profession again and upping the supply there. It’s probably best to wait and see, especially of you have not heavily relied on bought Rank 5s for your personal progression so far.

It is however unlikely that the prices will come back to the level they have been since yesterday. Our market tools give a pretty decent impression of what to expect, because you can manually adjust the cost of RPs. Enchantments do not suffer as much, because refining points are a comparably small part of their pricing. At worst you should expect a 25% increase across the board even if the price of RPs is going to multiply.

It’s another story for Artifacts, which feature a massive amount of RPs and could make a serious jump in pricing. At a certain point feeding becomes more viable even outside double weekend, but overall we might see the prices at least double for Mythic Artifacts. I would hold onto any Artifacts you might have and sell them at a later point. They are probable to gain value as items or feeders.

I doubt the change will instantly erase bots from the equation, but it’s very likely the cheapest days of Enchantments and Artifacts have passed. It’s not as big of a change as making drops from utility enchants bound however, which catapulted costs of RPs to up to ten times their pre-nerf value in Mod 5. I don’t think you will notice the change as much with your Enchantments and Runestones, because the bottleneck of those are the Marks of Potencys, but Mythic Artifacts could come close to what a piece of Legendary Artifact Equipment currently costs.

It’s not the worst thing in the world, but anything that adds to the refining grind has to be considered a net minus for the game, even if the target are bots. I certainly hope that the devs will monitor the availability of RPs and make more adjustments down the road.

What’s your take on the nerf? Share it in the comments below or visit our forum!

j0Shi

j0Shi

j0Shi plays the Neverwinter MMORPG since the open BETA in 2013 and is a regular contributor to the blog and the whole UN:Project. Originally a Guardian Fighter, he has built up ALTs of all classes and plays on BIS/near-BIS level.

4 thoughts on “How Big Will The Impact Of The Skill Node Nerf Be?

  • Avatar
    April 21, 2016 at 5:31 am
    Permalink

    Why not just make all RP bound to account, and reduce RP needs by 50%.. Why do they always do the must ludicrous things and not actual help players.

    Reply
    • Avatar
      April 21, 2016 at 7:37 am
      Permalink

      That would require more time. Knee-jerk reactions seem to be the status quo. Plus, now more people will buy Blood Rubies right?

      Reply
  • Avatar
    April 21, 2016 at 1:26 pm
    Permalink

    “Aim carefully and dont miss your own foot”, I think it is best practice for NW dev´s.

    As long RP -items drops ingame that way that players can use them that long there is possibility to farm them… but get rid bots will be another story and we will not see it on this context and if wondering why then you should kick first yourself on your head – wake up.

    Bot detection from gameclient – expencive
    Account creation captcha – rise cost and unefficient
    Ingame capthca – annoying for players and inefficient, expensive too

    Sooo we see that better hit legit players and shoot own foot because in long term stupid players spend anyway money on this crap?!!!!

    (…and bot´s bring more cheap stuff in AuctionHouse tooo, much cheaper than ZEN -shoppe, riiiight!!!)

    Reply
  • Avatar
    April 24, 2016 at 6:09 am
    Permalink

    To the Whiner wanting the Bot Removed, these bots help dropped the price of a stack of Rank 5 to 3000-5000 AD. So many people benefited from Bot Farming. A player can farm Demon HE hunting for 2 hours, get several Demon HE Rings. Salvage 3 rings and purchase 1-3 Rings easily plus doing your daily dungeons and skirmishes.

    Eventually, the prices will stabilize at a very high point. The higher price stack will require players spending more time to get 1 stack of rank 5.

    Lastly, I do not trust Cryptic promise to increase Rank 5 drop from mobs. An increase from 0.0001 to 0.0002 is still hilarious. Cryptic will not increase to the point that average players and the casual player can benefit.

    Cryptic keep making bad decision driving more players away. To compensate for lost income, they will continue making bad choices driving more players away.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.